In this piece, JOHN ALECHENU writes on the seemingly unending drama over the plot by members of the Nasarawa State House of Assembly to impeach Governor Umaru Al-Makura.
The successful ouster of erstwhile Governor of Adamawa State, Admiral Murtala Nyako, and the removal from office of the Deputy Governor of Enugu State, Sunday Oyebuchi, attention has now shifted to Nasarawa State.
Governor Umaru Al-Makura is without doubt facing the greatest battle of his political career yet. Indigenes and residents of the state have been gripped by a high sense of anxiety following attempts by members of the House of Assembly to impeach Al-Makura.
Members of the House earlier met and resolved to serve an impeachment notice on the governor after accusing him of several constitutional breaches.
The notice contained a series of allegations bordering on financial cum administrative malfeasance against the governor.
Clerk of the state House of Assembly, Mr. Ego Abashe, tried but failed to serve the governor the notice.
After several unsuccessful attempts to serve the governor, the Peoples Democratic Party-led House of Assembly resorted to substituted service.
It took several pages of paid advertisements to publish charges leveled against the governor demanding that he responds to them within a given period.
Amongst the allegations are: a case of the missing N2bn from the Local Government Joint Accounts; N3bn SURE-P funds spent by the Local Government Ministry; the alleged disappearance of N700m and N400m Federal Government flood intervention fund to the state.
Before the current face-off, the House had severally complained about the governor’s persistent refusal to implement resolutions passed by it.
Unable to get the governor to respond, the House asked the state Chief Judge to set up a seven-member investigative panel to look into the allegations and make recommendations.
As expected, the situation pitted the opposition All Progressives Congress against the Peoples Democratic Party at the state and federal levels.
The APC is of the view that the battle to force Al-Makura out of office is part of a grand design to decimate the number of states it controls as the nation prepares for the 2015 general elections.
The National Publicity Secretary of the APC, Alhaji Lai Mohammed said the plot against the sovernor is one of several plots orchestrated against governors on the platform of the APC by the PDP-led federal government. He said the party was not unaware of the desperation of the ruling party to foist itself on the Nigerian people come 2015.
In response, the Deputy National Publicity Secretary of the PDP, Alhaji Abdullahi Jalo, dismissed APC’s claims.
He said the PDP at the national level was busy providing quality leadership to Nigerians adding that what was happening in Nasarawa State was purely the internal affair of the state.
No sooner than the chief judge announced the composition of the seven-man panel than members of the House of Assembly began to cry foul.
They demanded for the reconstitution of the panel arguing that those appointed were allies of the governor.
The panel went ahead with its assignment nonetheless. It gave the governor a clean bill of health and quashed all the charges leveled against him.
The relief given to the governor by the seven-member panel constituted by the chief justice of the state appears to be temporary.
Members of the state House of Assembly who were obviously unsatisfied by the action of the panel petitioned the National Judicial Council urging it to investigate the state Chief Judge, Justice Umaru Dikko, for allegedly conniving with the executive in violating the 1999 Constitution as amended.
The decision by the House was contained in a resolution it passed after considering a matter of urgent public interest brought before it by the member representing Udege/Loko, Muhammad Baba Ibaku and seconded by Muhammad Okpede (Doma North).
The lawmakers alleged that the conduct of the chief judge in the impeachment saga was at variance with the provisions of Section 188(5) of the 1999 Constitution (as amended).
The House urged the National Judicial Council to investigate and sanction the chief judge to serve as a deterrent to other judges in the country.
This is even as members of the House suspended one of their own, Tanko Tunga (APC Awe South) for six months for allegedly attempting to snatch the mace during one of the rancorous sittings of the House.
Chairman of the House Committee on Information, Baba Ibaku, said as far as the House was concerned, the seven- member committee did not exist as such; its findings and recommendations remain a nullity.
He said “We don’t have a committee, they were wrongly selected we advised the CJ to re-constitute he slept and the only way we can wake him up is to write petition against him why are you sleeping with wrong people? And that is what we have just done.”
Unlike the case in Adamawa, supporters of governor Al-Makura took to the streets to protest moves by the House to impeach the governor. There were unconfirmed reports of some deaths.
Constituents of some of the members of the House of Assembly threatened to recall their representatives for daring to join those calling for the removal of the governor.
This situation forced some of the members to temporally relocate to Abuja while holding some of their sessions outside of the state House of Assembly Complex.
Spokesperson for the APC, Alhaji Lai Mohammed said “We are not surprised at what is going on. It is part of the impunity being perpetrated by the PDP but we are not in any way worried because the indictment of the governor cannot be justified nor sustained under any circumstance.
“Our stand is that any sitting of the House of Assembly conducted outside Lafia is an illegality and will have no effect. We are aware that the impeachment plot was being instigated by the PDP with the aim of decapitating opposition parties ahead of the 2015.”
President Goodluck Jonathan was widely reported to have advised the lawmakers against impeaching the governor. The President held separate meetings with the embattled governor and the aggrieved legislators in an attempt to broker a deal that will be mutually agreeable to both parties.
It appears that an attempt by Jonathan to intervene in the face-off has not yielded the desired results.
There are indications that the legislators are being prodded by prominent members of the ruling PDP who are indigenes of the state.
Those in this school of thought are of the view that it would not be in the interest of the party to have an opposition governor in charge of affairs less than six months to a major election.
It was learnt that hawks within the ruling party who have the ears of the President are insisting that members of the PDP-led House of Assembly should be given all the necessary tools to impeach the governor “for strategic reasons.”
Moderates are suggesting that pressure should be brought to bear on the governor to make him return to the PDP or he should be asked to resign.
Only on Wednesday, Al-Makura requested for a meeting with the legislators to discuss the deteriorating security situation in the state.
The legislators turned down his request citing the governor’s earlier decision to shun invitations from the House to discuss state matters.
Those familiar with the issue posit that the decision to turn down the governor’s request was to avoid “falling into a trap.”
Pundits argue that some political sins are hardly forgiven. They argue that Al-Makura’s decision to dump the PDP in the pursuit of his political ambition should be considered as such a sin because he not only ditched the party, he went ahead to defeat its candidate in 2011.
Senior Special Assistant, (Public Affairs) to Governor Al-Makura, Mr. Abdulrameed Kwara, expressed sadness that the desperation by proponents of the impeachment move against the governor has led to several acts of illegality.
“I want to tell you that these people are desperate to remove the governor. The mace that was used during one of their sittings is not that of the state Assembly.”
He further alleged that members of the assembly have also resorted to dropping the names of prominent political leaders in the North Central Zone in their bid to garner support.
Kwara expressed confidence that the move against the governor will fail because he remains a popular choice of the people.
Both parties to the dispute are considering the legal options while they explore a political solution to the impasse.
With the 2015 elections barely six months away, the last is yet to be heard about plots to impeach Al-Makura or any other governor considered to have committed an unpardonable political sin.